Skip to content

ECB violations and OATH hearings

OATH holds hearings on summonses from DOB, FDNY, Sanitation, DEP, and other city agencies. It took over the work of the Environmental Control Board, which is why DOB summonses are still called ECB violations.

ECB and OATH

The Environmental Control Board was an independent city tribunal that heard building code and quality-of-life violations issued by city agencies. It has since been merged into OATH, the city's central administrative court, and its cases are now heard by the OATH Hearings Division. ECB no longer exists as a separate body, but DOB summonses are still called ECB violations, and the name still appears on DOB records and older notices. An ECB violation and an OATH summons are the same kind of case.

Who issues and who decides

An agency inspector issues the summons. OATH holds the hearing, decides whether the violation stands, and sets the penalty. A building can have summonses from several agencies, and DOB's systems show only DOB's. Formin pulls OATH records by lot, so every agency's summonses appear in one list.

Missed hearings

If no one appears at a hearing, the case is decided by default at the maximum penalty, usually five times the standard amount. Hearings are often adjourned and rescheduled. Formin rechecks daily and adds each hearing date to the calendar.

Balances

Balances in the city's open data can lag behind payments. Formin checks each summons against OATH's ticket lookup and shows the balance OATH has on file.

Formin does not appear at hearings on your behalf. Dates and amounts come from OATH's records, and the official record governs.

See every OATH hearing on your buildings.

Add a building to see its summonses from every agency, with hearing dates and balances.