Skip to content

DOB violations

How the Department of Buildings records violations, how DOB violations differ from ECB violations, and what it takes to close each one.

BIS and DOB NOW

DOB records are kept in two systems. BIS is the legacy system and holds violations, complaints, and job filings from before DOB moved to DOB NOW. DOB NOW holds newer records. Many buildings have records in both, and some violations appear in each. Formin pulls from both systems and merges duplicates into a single row.

DOB violations, ECB violations, and complaints

DOB inspectors issue two kinds of violation. A DOB violation is a notice that a condition breaks the building code or a DOB rule; most carry no fine but stay open until DOB accepts proof that the condition was corrected. An ECB violation is a summons that carries a civil penalty. It is heard at OATH, which took over the Environmental Control Board, so the name stayed. One inspection can produce both for the same condition. A complaint is a report that has not been inspected yet.

DOB violation
Issued byDOB inspector
PenaltyUsually none
How it closesDOB accepts the correction, certification, or report the violation requires
ECB violation
Issued byDOB inspector; heard at OATH
PenaltyYes
How it closesDOB approves a certificate of correction, and the penalty is paid or dismissed
Complaint
Issued byFiled by the public, usually through 311
PenaltyNo
How it closesAn inspection closes it or results in a violation

Closing an ECB violation

An ECB violation has two parts to close. The penalty is decided at the OATH hearing and must be paid or dismissed. The condition is closed when DOB approves a certificate of correction. Paying the penalty does not close the violation, and neither does correcting the condition without filing. If no one appears at the hearing, the case is decided by default at the maximum penalty, usually five times the standard amount.

Addresses and identifiers

DOB tracks violations by BIN, the building identification number. OATH files summonses by lot, using the BBL. Corner buildings, complexes, and through-lots are often recorded under an address other than the one on the door, so a search by address can miss records. Formin tracks each building by its BIN and BBL.

ECB violation classes

ECB violations are classed by hazard. The class sets the correction deadline, the penalty, and whether the violation can be cured. Curing means correcting the condition and getting a certificate of correction accepted before the first hearing date, which removes the penalty. Penalties are set per infraction in the Buildings penalty schedule (1 RCNY §102-01); the amounts below are standard and vary by infraction. A repeat of the same violation within three years can carry a higher penalty that cannot be cured.

Class 1
MeaningImmediately hazardous
Correct withinImmediately
CurableNo
Penalty (hearing / default)$2,500 / $12,500
Class 2
MeaningMajor
Correct within60 days
CurableSome
Penalty (hearing / default)$1,250 / $6,250
Class 3
MeaningLesser
Correct within60 days
CurableYes
Penalty (hearing / default)Lower, varies

What Formin does

Formin rechecks each building daily against DOB BIS, DOB NOW, and OATH. For any violation it drafts a resolution plan with the tasks in order and an owner for each. Documents stay attached to the violation, and Ask Formin answers questions about a violation using its full record.

Official resources

Formin is independent of NYC agencies. Penalty amounts and deadlines are summarized from the Buildings penalty schedule and can change; the summons and the official record govern.

See every DOB violation on your buildings.

Add a building to see its open DOB and ECB violations from BIS and DOB NOW in one list.